Sciatica vs. Piriformis Syndrome: How to Tell the Difference

A lot of people come to Move Chiropractic after being told they have sciatica. They have done the stretches, taken the anti-inflammatories, maybe sat through a few weeks of treatment somewhere else, and the pain down the back of the leg is still there.
When that happens, one of the first questions I ask is whether “sciatica” was ever the full answer. Sciatica describes a symptom, pain along the path of the sciatic nerve, not a cause. The nerve can be irritated where it leaves the spine, deep in the buttock, or somewhere in between. Piriformis syndrome is one of the most common explanations people find when they start searching, and it is worth understanding how it differs.
If you want the basics on sciatica first, my post on whether chiropractic care can help with sciatica and the sciatica relief page are good places to start. This post is for people who are past the basics and trying to figure out why they are not getting better.

What Sciatica Usually Means
The sciatic nerve is formed by nerve roots that leave the lower spine, join together in the pelvis, pass through the buttock, and run down the back of the leg. When people say “sciatica,” they usually mean pain that travels from the low back or buttock down the leg.
The most common cause is irritation of a nerve root in the low back, called lumbar radiculopathy. That irritation usually comes from a disc bulge or herniation pressing on the nerve, or from narrowing around the nerve root, which becomes more common with age. My post on telling a muscle strain from a joint or disc problem explains how disc pain tends to behave.
What Piriformis Syndrome Is
The piriformis is a small muscle deep in the buttock that runs from the sacrum to the top of the thigh bone. It helps rotate the hip outward and stabilizes the hip when you walk and run. The sciatic nerve passes right next to it, and in some people, part of the nerve runs through the muscle.
Piriformis syndrome is the idea that the piriformis, or the tissue around it, irritates the sciatic nerve in the buttock rather than at the spine. Many clinicians now use the broader term “deep gluteal syndrome,” because the piriformis is not the only structure in that area that can irritate the nerve.
It is worth being honest about one thing: piriformis syndrome is less common than the internet suggests. It is real, but it is diagnosed after the more common causes have been ruled out, especially the low back. Plenty of people diagnose themselves with piriformis syndrome when the problem is actually coming from a disc.
Signs That Point Toward the Low Back
These patterns suggest the nerve is irritated where it leaves the spine:
Low back pain along with the leg pain, now or when it started
Leg pain that travels below the knee, sometimes into the foot or toes
Numbness or tingling in a specific strip of the leg or foot
Weakness, such as difficulty rising onto your toes or lifting the front of your foot
Pain that gets worse with bending forward, sitting for long periods, coughing, or sneezing
Leg pain that is usually worse than the back pain
Signs That Point Toward Piriformis or Deep Gluteal Syndrome
These patterns suggest the problem may be in the buttock:
Deep buttock pain on one side, sometimes spreading down the back of the thigh
Little or no low back pain
Pain that is worse sitting on hard surfaces or sitting on a wallet
Tenderness deep in the buttock, often near the middle of the cheek
Pain with crossing the leg or rotating the hip inward
Pain after long runs, hill work, or a sudden jump in activity
Usually no true weakness or reflex changes
These lists overlap, and you can have features of both. That is exactly why an exam matters more than a checklist.
Other Problems That Feel Like Sciatica
Several other problems cause pain in the buttock and down the leg and are easy to mistake for sciatica or piriformis syndrome:
SI joint irritation: pain near the dimple at the back of the pelvis, often worse with standing on one leg, climbing stairs, or rolling over in bed
Hip joint problems: pain in the groin or the side of the hip, stiffness, and trouble putting on socks. The hip pain page covers these.
High hamstring tendon pain: pain right at the sit bone, worse with sitting and with stretching the hamstring. It is very common in runners.
Referred pain from low back joints: an ache in the buttock and thigh that usually stops above the knee and is not truly nerve pain
Each of these needs a different plan. Treating SI joint pain or a hamstring tendon problem as sciatica is one of the most common reasons people do not improve.
How I Tell the Difference
There is no single test that diagnoses piriformis syndrome. The answer comes from putting several pieces together:
Your history: where the pain started, what it travels to, what makes it better or worse, and how sitting, bending, walking, and running affect it
Movement testing: watching how the back and hips move and which movements bring on your leg symptoms
Neurological screening: reflexes, strength, and sensation in both legs to check whether a nerve root is involved
Nerve tension tests: such as a straight leg raise and a slump test, which are often provocative when a lumbar nerve root is irritated
Hip and buttock tests: rotation and stretch positions that load the piriformis and deep hip muscles, along with palpation of the area
Ruling out the look-alikes: testing the SI joint, the hip joint, and the hamstring tendon
By the end of the first visit, you will know which explanation fits best and why. If the picture is unclear or something does not add up, I will say so, and imaging or a referral may be the next step. My post on what to expect at your first chiropractic appointment walks through the first visit.
Why “Sciatica” Sometimes Does Not Get Better
When someone has been treated for sciatica for weeks without progress, I usually find one of these:
The diagnosis was off. The pain is coming from the SI joint, the hip, or a hamstring tendon instead of the nerve.
The wrong stretches. Aggressive piriformis and hamstring stretches can irritate an already sensitive nerve root. If stretching makes your leg pain worse, stop and get it assessed.
Only the painful spot was treated. Rubbing the buttock helps for a day, but if a disc or stiff hip is driving the problem, the pain returns.
Too much rest, or the wrong kind of activity. Most people with sciatic symptoms improve with the right kind of movement, not bed rest.
Sitting habits never changed. Long periods of sitting, especially slumped or on a hard seat, can keep either problem irritated.
How I Treat Each Problem
When the Low Back Is the Source
Finding movements and positions that reduce leg symptoms, so the pain centralizes back toward the spine
Spinal adjustments and mobilization when stiffness is contributing and it is appropriate for your presentation
Gentle nerve mobility exercises once the nerve is less irritated
Core and hip strengthening with therapeutic exercises that you progress at home
Changes to sitting, lifting, and training while the nerve settles
When the Piriformis or Deep Hip Is the Source
Dry needling for trigger points in the piriformis and the surrounding glute muscles. My post on dry needling near Angier explains what it feels like.
Soft tissue and muscle therapy to reduce tension around the nerve
Extremity adjustments and mobilization when the hip or SI joint is stiff
Hip strengthening, especially for the glutes, which often work too little while the piriformis works too hard
Running and training adjustments, such as mileage, hills, and stride, when activity is the trigger
Many patients need a mix of both. If the hip and low back are both contributing, the plan addresses both.
When to Get Medical Care Right Away
Most sciatic pain improves with conservative care, but some symptoms need urgent attention. Go to the emergency room or call your physician right away if you have:
Numbness in the groin, inner thighs, or the area you would sit on a saddle
New difficulty controlling your bladder or bowels
Weakness that is getting worse, such as foot drop or a leg that gives out
Leg pain with fever, unexplained weight loss, or a history of cancer
Severe pain after a fall, car accident, or other trauma
These are uncommon, but they are important. If any show up during the exam, I will refer you immediately.
What Move Chiropractic Does Not Offer
Move Chiropractic does not offer laser therapy, shockwave therapy, traction, or injections. If imaging, an injection, or a surgical consult makes sense for your case, I will tell you and help you get there.
You see me at every visit, not an assistant, not whoever is available, so the person who did your exam is the one tracking whether the plan is working. Care plans are built around your situation, with no long-term contracts required on day one. You can read more about Dr. David Carter’s background.
Sciatica and Piriformis FAQs
Can piriformis syndrome cause pain below the knee?
It can, but it is less common. Pain that travels below the knee into the foot, especially with numbness or weakness, points more strongly toward a nerve root in the low back. That is one of the main things I check at the first visit.
Should I stretch my piriformis if I have sciatica?
Not until you know what is causing the pain. A gentle piriformis stretch can help when the problem is in the buttock. When a disc is irritating the nerve, the same stretch can make leg symptoms worse. If any stretch increases your leg pain, stop and get it assessed.
Do I need an MRI to tell the difference?
Usually not at first. A thorough history and exam can tell most cases apart. An MRI makes sense when there is significant or worsening weakness, red flag symptoms, or no improvement after several weeks of appropriate care. MRI findings also need to match the exam, because disc bulges are common in people with no pain at all.
How long does piriformis syndrome take to get better?
Many people improve noticeably within a few weeks once the right areas are being treated and they change what was aggravating it. Lumbar nerve root irritation often takes longer, sometimes six to twelve weeks. You will get an honest timeline at your first visit.
Can sitting cause piriformis syndrome?
Long periods of sitting, especially on hard surfaces or with a wallet in your back pocket, can aggravate it. Sitting can also aggravate disc-related sciatica, which is one reason sitting alone does not tell the two apart.
Does dry needling help sciatica?
Dry needling can help when tight, irritated muscles in the buttock and hip are contributing, which is common in piriformis and deep gluteal syndrome. It is less effective on its own when a disc is the main source, although it can still ease the muscle guarding that comes with it.
Schedule an Assessment in Angier
If you have been told you have sciatica and you are not getting better, a thorough assessment can tell you whether the plan is aimed at the right problem. Move Chiropractic is located at 149A Logan Ct, Suite A, in Angier and sees patients Monday through Friday by appointment. No referral is needed. Patients come from Angier, Fuquay-Varina, Lillington, Willow Springs, Coats, Benson, Erwin, and Buies Creek.
To schedule, visit the New Patients page, or call or text (984) 355-3587. For more on how I treat sciatic pain, see the sciatica relief page.





Comments